Best toothpaste to remove plaque and tartar (Tartar removal toothpaste Reviews)

Plaque and tartar buildup can lead to a variety of dental problems like tooth decay and gum disease. The American Dental Association (ADA) recommends choosing a toothpaste that contains fluoride to prevent cavities, has the ADA Seal of Acceptance, and suits your specific needs:

“Some products aim to whiten teeth, while others help relieve tooth sensitivity. There are toothpastes made especially for people with gum disease or other medical conditions. Your dentist can recommend the right toothpaste for your oral health needs.”

When looking to specifically target plaque and tartar, the dental professionals suggest using a toothpaste containing pyrophosphates, a compound that helps prevent calcification of plaque into tartar.

Tartar removal toothpaste Reviews

Tartar removal toothpaste Reviews

Below are 10 top-rated toothpastes containing pyrophosphates and other plaque-fighting ingredients to remove built-up plaque and tartar.

1. Crest Pro-Health Advanced Toothpaste

Key features:

– Contains stannous fluoride for anticavity protection

– Includes polyphosphate for tartar control

– Has a smooth, non-scratchy texture

Pros Cons
  • Fights plaque bacteria even 12 hours after brushing
  • Leaves breath feeling fresh for hours
  • Provides long-lasting tartar protection
  • Has a strong medicinal taste some may not like
  • More expensive than regular toothpaste

2. Colgate Total Advanced Whitening Toothpaste

Key features:

– Has triclosan to combat plaque germs

– Includes sodium fluoride for cavity prevention 

– Contains micro-polishers for stain removal

Pros Cons
  • Fights bacteria on teeth, tongue, cheeks and gums
  • Whitens teeth by 2 shades in 2 weeks
  • Leaves mouth feeling clean for up to 12 hours
  • Triclosan safety has been questioned by some
  • Can cause mild tooth sensitivity
  • Has a strong peppermint taste

3. Arm & Hammer Advance White Extreme Whitening Toothpaste

Key features:

– Contains baking soda for stain removal

– Includes peroxide for whitening

– Has fluoride for cavity protection

Pros Cons
  • Whitens teeth up to 10 shades in 6 months
  • Helps remove stains from coffee, wine, etc.
  • Baking soda and peroxide fight plaque buildup
  • Can increase tooth sensitivity
  • Has a very strong mint flavor
  • More abrasive than some toothpastes

4. Sensodyne Pronamel Gentle Whitening Toothpaste

Key features:

– Contains stannous fluoride

– Includes sodium fluoride

– Has low abrasion silica for whitening

Pros Cons
  • Gentle on tooth enamel and dentin
  • Helps strengthen and reharden enamel
  • Freshens breath for up to 12 hours
  • Takes longer to whiten than peroxide pastes
  • Has a higher price point
  • Flavor is not very strong

5. Crest 3D White Radiant Mint Toothpaste

Key features:

– Has sodium hexametaphosphate

– Includes stannous fluoride

– Contains silica for polishing

Pros Cons
  • Removes over 90% of surface stains
  • Leaves teeth 2 shades whiter in 2 weeks
  • Has a nice subtle mint flavor
  • Can cause temporary tooth sensitivity
  • Is a more abrasive whitening toothpaste
  • Has higher cost than regular pastes

6. Hello Antiplaque + Whitening Toothpaste

Key features:

– Contains hydrogen peroxide 

– Has no artificial flavors/sweeteners

– Uses xylitol as a sweetener

Pros Cons
  • Whitens teeth gently without peroxide
  • Fights plaque and freshens breath
  • Has a great tea tree oil mint taste
  • May not remove deep set stains
  • Is more expensive than regular brands
  • Taste and texture takes some adjustment

7. Tom’s of Maine Simply White Toothpaste

Key features:
– Includes hydrated silica for plaque removal
– Contains sodium lauryl sulfate (SLS)-free formula
– Has naturally-sourced calcium and silica

Pros Cons
  • Whitens teeth without harsh abrasives
  • SLS-free formula is gentle on gums
  • Fights plaque buildup naturally
  • May take longer to see whitening results
  • Has a milder mint taste than most pastes
  • Usually costs more than regular toothpastes

8. Jason Healthy Mouth Anti-Cavity & Tartar Control Toothpaste

Key features:
– Has tea tree oil, grapefruit seed extract
– Contains calcium carbonate crystals
– Includes aloe vera for gum protection

Pros Cons
  • All natural ingredients fight plaque bacteria
  • Leaves breath feeling fresh for hours
  • Strengthens enamel against acid erosion
  • Texture is grainy and takes getting used to
  • Flavor is very different from regular paste
  • Usually costs more than drugstore brands

9. Supersmile Professional Whitening Toothpaste

Key features:
– Contains tetrasodium pyrophosphate
– Includes calcium peroxide for whitening
– Has a low-abrasion formula

Pros Cons
  • Visibly whitens teeth in just 1 week
  • Helps prevent and remove tartar
  • Leaves mouth feeling clean and fresh
  • Comes in a small, expensive tube
  • Can cause temporary tooth sensitivity
  • Has a strong spearmint-wintergreen flavor

10. Marvis Whitening Mint Toothpaste

Key features:
– Contains sorbitol, sodium phosphate
– Includes fluoride for cavity prevention
– Has a unique thick gel texture

Pros Cons
  • Effectively whitens and brightens teeth
  • Leaves breath feeling fresh for hours
  • Has an invigorating mint flavor
  • Is often more expensive than other pastes
  • Takes time to get used to thick texture
  • Mint flavor may be too strong for some

Final Thoughts

Choosing the right toothpaste requires balancing factors like plaque and tartar removal, cavity prevention, whitening, gum health, and taste preferences. Consulting your dentist can ensure you find the best toothpaste for your specific oral care needs. Using a toothpaste with plaque-fighting ingredients will keep your smile brighter, teeth cleaner, and gums healthier.


When selecting toothpaste, it’s not about the flashy packaging, but the ingredients inside that matter. According to the American Dental Association (ADA), certain ingredients can help with tooth sensitivity, reducing gum inflammation, preventing tartar buildup, enamel protection, teeth whitening, and freshening breath. Focus on these according to your needs, in addition to having the ADA seal of approval for your own peace of mind.

Fluoride is a crucial ingredient in conventional toothpaste. It strengthens teeth and prevents tooth decay by protecting enamel from acid attacks caused by food and drinks. Fluoride in toothpaste and tap water together helps enamel remineralize, making teeth more resistant to cavities and decay.

SLS creates the foaming action in toothpaste. While it can aid in thorough cleaning, the effectiveness of your toothbrush’s bristles plays a more significant role in plaque and calculus removal.

Hydrogen peroxide in toothpaste helps remove both surface and intrinsic stains from teeth, resulting in a brighter, whiter smile.

Xylitol, a sweetener, not only enhances toothpaste flavor but also helps eliminate harmful bacteria responsible for tooth decay.

Toothpaste might contain abrasives like calcium carbonate, which aid in removing surface stains and disrupting bacterial colonies. Toothpaste with a relative dentin abrasion of 250 or lower is safe for daily use.

While mint is common, toothpaste comes in various flavors like cinnamon or tea tree oil. Try different flavors to find one you enjoy, as taste preference varies.

For specialized needs like sensitive teeth, choose toothpaste formulated for that purpose. Brands like Sensodyne, with ingredients like potassium nitrate, can help soothe sensitive teeth.

Toothpaste usually has a two-year expiration date. Expired toothpaste may harden and become less effective, so it’s best to use it before it expires.

For children, a smear the size of a grain of rice is recommended until age three. From three years to adulthood, a pea-sized amount is sufficient. It’s not about quantity but allowing the toothpaste to stay on after brushing for the active ingredients to work effectively. Avoid rinsing right after brushing to maximize the benefits of toothpaste.


  • Editorial team

    A team comprising oral health care professionals, researchers, and professional Writers, striving to impart you with the knowledge to improve your oral health, and that of your loved ones. 

  • Lilly

    Lilly, aka, Liza Lee, is a passionate community oral health officer and our lead writer. She's not only well-versed in performing a multitude of dental procedures, including preventive, restorative, and cosmetic, but also an avid writer. Driven by the significant oral health burden all around her, Lilly strives to build capacity and promote oral health. She envisions making a lasting impact by advancing research, prevention, and promotion efforts to alleviate oral health disparities. Please share your views and opinions on my posts.

Leave a Comment

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

Scroll to Top